Anyone who knows me knows that Scream is my favourite movie. I love the hell out of it. So much so that I named my blog after it. I've seen it more times than I can count, I know countless obscure facts about the production, I can recite the entire movie beginning to end by heart, in short: I am obsessed. The movie (and the entire franchise) holds a really dear place in my heart not only because it's an awesome movie, but because of the memories it conjures of my first time watching it and of the person I watched it with. I could go on and on, but to sum it up Scream means a lot to me.
Which is why when news of a TV series broke, I had a lot of mixed emotions. On one hand it was Scream and it was TV, two of my favourite things! On the other hand, it featured none of the original cast, wasn't even related to the storyline of the original movies and more importantly didn't have the involvement of series mastermind Kevin Williamson. When the official synopsis was released (a group of teens involved in an incident surrounding a viral video which sets off a string of murders, and threatens to uncover hidden secrets from the town's past) my emotions were mixed up even more. Sure it has the teens being murdered part I was expecting/hoping for, but this viral video stuff seems like it's trying too hard to be current. And don't even get me started on the town's secrets! In any case, mixed emotions or not, there was no chance I wasn't going to watch it.
And so I did. And to be honest, I'm still digesting what I saw. I may not post this straight away, I may have to come back to it after sleeping on it and see how I feel after some distance. But in any case this is a gut-reaction review.
Going in, I tried as much as possible to view the series separate from the movies and not to compare the two, however it was clear in the pilot at least that comparisons were welcomed, encouraged even. Case in point, the opening scene featuring rich girl Nina (Bella Thorne) home alone in her sprawling hi-tech house, being watched and tormented by an unseen stalker (naturally via text message, video chat and what looked like Snapchat...) before being butchered, was clearly an overt homage to the iconic opening scene of the original movie featuring Drew Barrymore (who just used an old fashioned telephone!).
![]() |
She's screaming...geddit? |
And this problem sadly isn't snuffed out with Nina. None of the characters are particularly compelling. The genius of original movie writer Kevin Williamson was that he really made you care for the characters in such a short space of time, so much so that when they inevitably met their maker, it really affected you. After a whole episode however, there are no characters who I am particularly endeared towards or frankly whom I actually care about. We have Emma (Willa Fitzgerald), who I guess is our Sidney stand-in and (for the moment at least) our lead, Brooke (Carlson Young), another rich bitch who exists only to give dirty looks and make catty comments, new guy Keiran (Amadeus Serafini), brooding-yet-handsome with a dark past, and Audrey (Bex Taylor-Klaus), loner bi-curious girl at the centre of the viral video scandal. We also have a bunch of male jock-like characters with interchangeable names and personalities (one of whom is Emma's boyfriend), who don't add anything other than inappropriate comments and sex references. The only semi-interesting character is self-professed film-geek Noah (he's our Randy substitute) and only because he at least has a clearly defined role in the series. He's the one to make all the self-aware comments and pop-culture references and to explain 'the rules' to the other characters and by extension the audience. But I don't care about any of them. Not yet at least.
![]() |
Not a likeable one in the bunch... |
In fact Noah's speech towards the end of the episode perfectly encapsulates this problem in an appropriately meta nature. When asked how the story ends he says: "You need to forget it's a horror story. That someone might die at every turn. You see, you have to care if the smoking hot lit teacher seems a little too interested in his female students. You have to care if the team wins the big game. You have to care if the smart, pretty girl forgives the dumb jock...You root for them, you love them. So that when they are brutally murdered, it hurts." On one hand it's a clever deconstruction of effective characterisation in slasher films, but on the other, it almost feels like a justification or a disclaimer to the audience: 'Please give us time to make you like these characters'. Which is all well and good, but with any good series, you should really like at least one of the characters by the end of the first episode and barring a couple who have potential to become at least mildly interesting, when the show asks us to 'love' the characters, I just don't. Even liking them will take some time.
The irony is, that what many people cite as one of the advantages of television over movies (ie. the ability to develop characters over a longer period of time, and to really get to know them) is sadly not evident here in the slightest, and frankly may not even be true. Well-written characters are well-written characters regardless of whether you have two hours or ten to flesh them out. Granted it's only been one episode but based on what I've seen so far, my reaction to most of these characters' eventual deaths, regardless of how long I've spent with them, will most likely be no more than a nonplussed shrug.
Of course much of the fun of the slasher genre is trying to work out who the killer is, but the pilot tries so hard to paint almost every character in the light that they could be the killer that they almost stop being characters and simply exist as suspects and/or knife-bait.
It's not even the fact that the characters are all largely teen stereotypes. The original movie dealt in stereotypes too (as all good slashers should), but worked to flip our expectations of these stereotypes to produce something fresh and interesting. In the series' pilot episode, our expectations are met and that's all. There's no clever twist on these archetypes, just paint-by-numbers teen television with a faint slasher aftertaste.
And this cookie-cutter teen television element isn't limited to characterisation either. Airing on MTV, I expected a certain 'catering to a demographic' feel to the show, which is exactly what I got and, being at least partially a member of that demographic, I appreciated it for what it was. There was just something about certain moments which screamed of trying too hard to be modern and cool. Having an iPad with Nina's picture on it propped up on a table at her 'memorial party' for example. Really? A regular old photograph wouldn't have sufficed? Nina sauntering through her house telling her phone to turn on lights is another eye-roll-inducing example. It's small things like this that make it overly evident how much the show wants us to know that it's a 'modern update'. We get it, technology exists and teenagers use it!
In terms of plot, not a whole lot happened after the opening death-scene, with much of the episode just introducing the characters and their relationships in the aftermath of one of their own being murdered (a fact which none of the group seem to really care all that much about). It was probably a wise decision to only have the one death-scene in the pilot, in the interest of maintaining the narrative over the entire season (or even perhaps multiple seasons), and despite not much actually happening after the first 10 minutes or so, the episode did maintain a tense atmosphere throughout.
The only relatively intriguing development plot-wise (and I mean intriguing in the sense that I'm interested to see what they'll do with it, more-so than I find it an interesting thread) is the inclusion of a town 'legend', a tragedy that happened 20 years prior involving Brandon James, a deformed teenager who went on a killing spree after being spurned by the object of his affections. It's a strange addition to the plot, but I guess something which the show needed above and beyond simply 'teens use phones and get killed', however I'm not sure it's the right fit for a Scream series. It feels more akin to something like Prom Night or My Bloody Valentine, both excellent slasher films, but with a distinctly different tone to Scream.
Which kind've sums up my overall feeling about the show at this early stage. It's a decent effort as far as a teen horror show is concerned, and features all of the guilty pleasures which one would expect and lap up, and there are hints at potential in certain areas. It's a fun and well-executed slasher-esque television show, it just isn't a Scream television show.
And here's where the comparisons come into play in a big way. Scream to me isn't the blood and the self-referential nature, although of course those are huge factors in it's appeal. Scream to me, is the characters, it's the setting. Scream to me is Sidney Prescott. It's Gale Weathers. It's Dewey Riley. It's Randy Meeks. It's Woodsboro! Without those characters and the heart with which Kevin Williamson instilled them, it's just not Scream.
![]() |
Love these guys! #HolyTrinity |
Despite sharing the same premise of being a self-aware slasher, the movie and the TV show are both very different in tone. Yes, the film featured snarky teens and stereotypical scenarios, but it was infused with a real sense of personality. You got a real sense that the town of Woodsboro was deeply affected by the events taking place, yet teens will be teens and life still goes on. It was this dark (and sometimes not-so-dark) humour and melodrama, balanced with the right amount of heart and groundedness, that gave it its memorable tone. Now I'm in no way saying that the TV series has to have that exact same combination or that it needs to make me feel exactly the same way, but it needs to make me feel something, and so far the only thing it's making me feel is frustration over the fact that, due to its existence, we'll probably never get a Scream 5.
Ultimately despite its shortcomings, I really enjoyed the pilot and I'm sure I'll continue to enjoy the series for what it is, as I love anything horror-related and slasher-adjacent. I mean, who am I kidding, I'm gonna watch the hell out of this show until it gets cancelled, and I'll probably enjoy every minute. I just don't know that it really needed to be brought under the Scream umbrella. With that said however, it won't negate the love I have for the original movies, or abolish them from existence, so I see no reason why the two can't exist side-by-side. Like a protective mother shielding her young from the world however, I am concerned that those whose first experience of Scream is through this series will not be getting the right impression. It's my instinct to shout out 'The movies are better!' to anyone who will listen. However, as much as that's true (the movies are better obviously, just to reiterate!), it doesn't really matter. They'll still be there after the show ends, and no doubt the series will lead many people to discovering the movies and enjoying them for the first time themselves. Lucky bastards.
And who knows, maybe we will get a Scream 5 somewhere down the line, but I can't help but feel that this series is an 'instead of' rather than an 'as well as' in regards to further Scream-related media. In any case, whether it leads to another big-screen instalment or simply becomes a post-script to the Scream franchise's legacy, it had better be bloody worth it!
LINGERING THOUGHTS:
- Will this be a multi-season show, or an anthology series a la American Horror Story or the upcoming Scream Queens? Can a series with a slasher premise maintain a multi-season narrative? I'd love to see a series succeed in this task, but it's difficult to envision how it'll work. If it's going to live up to it's premise, not many of the cast will be left by the end of this season!
- The new 'updated' mask is suitably creepy, but I have to question whether it was necessary to change it. I've heard the reasoning that the original mask is too closely associated with the Scary Movie series now to be scary anymore, but I call BS to that. It's still scary as hell and besides that, it's iconic to the franchise. Mixed feelings again!
![]() |
Looks more 'Blow' than 'Scream'... |
- Despite having Horror Master (and a personal favourite of mine) Wes Craven on-board as Executive Producer, I didn't feel his hand in the pilot at all. If only he'd directed as originally rumoured perhaps it would have had that authentic Scream vibe. It'll be interesting to see how much involvement he actually has with the series going forward.
- I'm not sure whether or not I'll continue to review this week-by-week, I may just bullet-point my thoughts each week, or do a round-up every few episodes. Needs thought. Suggestions?